Should parents take their children out of school during school time?

I argued on BBC Breakfast that they should not. I cited the example of ‘Katie’ (not the pupils’ real name) who had missed weeks of school because her parents were taking her out regularly of school during term time, going on cheap holidays. They lied to the school and said that she was ill. There was nothing the school could do. Katie missed lots of valuable lesson time and did not complete her coursework as a result, the holiday time was wasted time for her. Other people emailed the show to point out that teachers waste valuable time helping pupils who have been away on holiday catch-up when they could be helping other pupils, which is certainly true.

Comments

2 responses to “Should parents take their children out of school during school time?”

  1. Nonsense each situation should be judged on the individual. Travel in the widest sense is an educational experience that no amount of ‘international week’ can surpass. An understanding school should be able to provide the family with appropriate material for the child to cover in their absence or suggest the child complete a journal covering the period away which can reflect the school term topics. No teacher-student time is wasted if the focus is on imparting knowledge that creates positive learning. If planned the teacher can share the experience with the class and the child feels their time away has been rewarding. Teachers spend far too much time complaining these days and schools are certainly not far from been a mafia.

    sherry

  2. I take your point, but the problem is that in the big picture, the pupils who miss school the most do the worst. While there may be individual cases where pupils have profitted from going on holiday during term-time, mostly this is not the case. Furthermore, it’s very difficult for teachers to incorporate pupils discussing their holidays during term-time into their lessons. This could cause resentment in the classroom and encourage other pupils to do the same, which, as I’ve said, doesn’t help things.

    francisgilbert

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related reading

  • Should parents be banned from sports’s days?

    This is a tricky one. Sports’ days are about children doing their best on track and field and not about parents soaking up reflected glory. One headteacher has done exactly this though: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1197284/Schools-bar-parents-sports-day–paedophiles.html?ITO=1490 I appeared on BBC Breakfast explaining why the head had good reasons to do this, given the horrific climate that the internet […]

  • Should parents pay for solicitors to help them get the school of their choice?

    Emphatically not! You’re far better off reading a school’s admission criteria very carefully and reading books like my Working The System. A BBC investigation has revealed that parents are paying lawyers thousands of pounds to get into the school of their choice. I appeared on BBC Radio Wales and BBC Radio 5 Live and explained that […]

  • How to choose a school: by teachers for parents

    Tis the season when schools are trying to woo potential parents at open days. How can you tell what a school is really like behind the facade? Here is our guide by those who know: the teachers. This article first appeared in The Guardian. I know from bitter experience that appearances can be deceptive. I […]

  • Are the school summer holidays just too long?

    Observer columnist Barbara Ellen and teacher Francis Gilbert debate whether children and parents would benefit from a shorter summer break Barbara Ellen: Francis, I would always have argued that school holidays are too long. For parents, that is. A case of: “My child, I would fight a lion for you, but if you ask me to […]

  • Has your child missed out on a primary school place? Our expert guide for worried parents: The New Day

    This article provides some invaluable advice for parents, helping them deal with the disappointment of not getting their preferred place for their child at a school of their choice.