Should a teacher be sacked for writing about his/her pupils?

Leonora Rustamova was suspended from her post as English teacher this January because she wrote a book about her pupils. At first glance, it sounds monstrously unfair: a teacher tries to motivate the disaffected teenage boys in her class by writing a book about them. Initially, her headteacher was very supportive of the plan, but then had second thoughts when a senior teacher complained. Rustamova published the book on the internet, claiming that this was a mistake. She also named her pupils with their real names, claiming that some of them had sexual fantasies about her. Furthermore, soon after the pupils left the school, she invited the pupils for a barbecue and they slept over in the same house with her, staying in the house of another teacher. The other teacher was sacked too.

Calder High School in Mytholmroyd, West Yorkshire, has been caught up in a media firestorm with this story. The school has remained tight-lipped though, pending an hearing with the GTCE (General Teaching Council for England).

 

At first, I felt sympathetic for Rustamova, but the more I listened to her on the Radio 5 interview, the more I felt she was being disingenuous. She claimed that she wasn’t aware that putting the book onto a self-publishing website would mean that it wasn’t widely available. She didn’t seem to think inviting the pupils for a sleepover was wrong — or even naming them. One pupil went on air to defend her. Again, this felt weird. The boy appeared as though he hadn’t fully processed the incident.

Links to the story: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1167105/Teacher-Leonora-Rustamova-sacked-writing-fictional-book-pupils-sexual-fantasies-her.html

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/west_yorkshire/8071857.stm

 

http://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/Teacher-in-shock-over-racybook.5433875.jp

http://famewatcher.com/2009/04/leonora-rustamova-stop-dont-read-this.html

 

I appeared on Radio 5 Live talking about the case and explained that Rustamova had blindly published the book without thinking about the consequences, that it felt too much like an ego-trip rather than a genuine educational strategy, that she shouldn’t have invited the pupils for the sleepover or named the pupils.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related reading

  • Are too few incompetent teachers being sacked?

    Some commentators have felt that there are as many as 17,000 incompetent teachers in our schools, and yet only a handful of them have been sacked officially. A recent Panorama programme suggested that these teachers are passed from school to school because headteachers are too frightened to sack them. It’s basically easier for a head […]

  • Should teachers use force to break up pupils who are fighting?

    The question is a tricky one. As a young teacher, I got into trouble for pulling two pupils apart while they were scrapping on the floor. One of the pupils claimed I’d manhandled him and complained to a senior member of staff. Luckily, my manager knew what the child was like and didn’t believe his […]

  • Yoga for all pupils, and other alternative schools

    Schools with a difference are enjoying a renaissance — but what sort of education do they offer? Yoga, meditation, gardening and learning through play — not your traditional school fare. But “alternative” education has never been a hotter topic for many parents in Britain. Tired of a diet of uniforms and exams that many schools […]

  • Vital moral question: should a teacher have pupils as friends on Facebook?

    I don’t really take Facebook seriously, but increasingly as I mindlessly click on people to be my friends, being confronted with some pupils I teach, I click them in thinking: friend’ on Facebook doesn’t mean ‘friend’ in real life. It’s just a label for someone you don’t mind snooping over your silly Facebook page. I […]

  • Why do so many people feel sympathy for a teacher acquitted for attempted murder?

    The Peter Harvey case has come at a particularly interesting time, just before one of the most turbulent elections of recent times, and at a point where there is a crisis of confidence in our schools. Peter Harvey battered a pupil of his with a dumb-bell, fracturing his skull, while saying “Die, die, die!” Harvey […]