Two In A Tower and The Trumpet Major

Going through a major Thomas Hardy phase, as if teaching ‘Far From The Madding Crowd’ wasn’t enough. I felt his novella, ‘Two In A Tower’ is a marvellous achievement. It’s about a poor, young, pretty astronomer who falls in love with an unhappily married lady of the manor. The pair secretly marry, only to have their plans for happiness ruined by — as ever with Hardy — FATE! It’s the way Hardy paints a portrait of the neurotic, anxious woman and describes the endlessly circular conversations that lovers have that makes this such a subtle portrait. ‘The Trumpet Major’ is a much more inferior work but with moments of greatness: two brothers fall in love with the same girl and there’s endless messing about as to who will win her. The set-pieces, the descriptions of England preparing for the invasion of Napoleon, are great, but the characters felt undefined and unconvincing to me. The villain of the piece, Festus, a cowardly bullying soldier, never amounts to much, and the heroine is very irritating without being psychologically convincing.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related reading

  • Betrayal — Chapters 27-46

    What is betrayal? What’s your definition of it? Situations – what would you do? You learn that your partner is havinng an affair You learn after you have committed to each other that you partner had an important relationship they haven’t told you about You learn your partner has a secret love child An attractive […]

  • The Well-Beloved By Thomas Hardy

    Now this is a great novella. A sculptor growing up on a small, quarried island just off the Dorset coast, is afflicted by this condition whereby he falls in love with ‘the well-beloved’ in a woman, and that this essence of feminity, this life principle, jumps from woman to woman in a maddeningly capricious fashion. […]

  • The Man Who Went Into The West

  • Far From The Madding Crowd — CHARACTERISATIONS

    Learning objectives To learn how to answer exam questions To learn about CHARACTERISATIONS as opposed to CHARACTERS Important definition – COPY THIS, LEARN IT! CHARACTERISATION is how and why an author presents a character in the way he does. CHARACTER is a person in a novel WHY does more sophisticated analysis discuss CHARACTERISATIONS as opposed […]

  • How successfully does Hardy open Far From The Madding Crowd?

    Learning Objectives To learn about the techniques Hardy uses to create a suspenseful opening to Far From The Madding Crowd To learn about the contexts of Hardy’s novel An important point Starter activity: put these elements of the opening in the correct order Gabriel Oak loses his sheep Oak is rescued from suffocation in his […]